Will Venable winning American League Manager of the Year should make White Sox fans smile. It should also make Jerry Reinsdorf a little uncomfortable. When your manager earns recognition for getting more out of a roster than practically anyone expected, the appropriate ownership response is to give him more to work with. It is not to congratulate yourself for discovering how far you can stretch a dollar.
Venable earned this one. The White Sox went 84-78, improved by 24 wins and reached the postseason for the first time since 2021. They even beat Houston in the Wild Card Series, delivering the franchise’s first playoff series victory since 2005. Venable received 15 first-place votes and edged Tampa Bay’s Kevin Cash, 111 points to 98. That is a pretty convincing argument that something meaningful changed on the South Side.
But let’s separate two things. Appreciating what Venable accomplished and accepting the financial limitations under which he accomplished it.
Those are not the same conversation.
About 90 miles north, the Milwaukee Brewers just offered a useful demonstration of what a lower-payroll organization can accomplish. They won 103 games and the World Series with a payroll of approximately $146.2 million, ranking 19th in baseball. They were not shopping in the sport’s luxury aisle, but they still put together a championship team.
That should be embarrassing for any owner who treats limited spending as an explanation rather than a challenge.
The Brewers are not proof that payroll does not matter. They are proof that spending intelligently matters—and that low payroll does not have to mean refusing to make meaningful investments. Their championship came with a payroll well above the roughly $99 million that MLB Trade Rumors reported as Chicago’s final 2026 figure. Accounting methods can vary, but neither number suggests these franchises were operating near baseball’s financial penthouse.
For Reinsdorf, Milwaukee should be an uncomfortable comparison. Nobody is asking the White Sox to win every winter’s bidding war. Fans are asking why a team representing Chicago should treat a competitive payroll like an unreasonable extravagance.
Venable’s award makes that question louder, not quieter. He has supplied evidence that the manager’s office is not the problem. Now ownership needs to supply evidence that winning will be supported rather than merely applauded.
Which brings us to Dustin May.
The White Sox officially announced his three-year, $52.5 million contract Wednesday, and credit where it belongs. That is an actual commitment, not an invitation to spring training dressed up as an offseason strategy. May arrives after splitting 2026 between St. Louis and, fittingly, the World Series champion Brewers.
There is potential here, but let’s not pretend the Sox bought a finished ace. May posted a 4.70 ERA across a career-high 31 starts, striking out 144 batters in 145⅔ innings. His Milwaukee regular-season ERA was 5.65. This is a bet on an arm and a better future, not payment for a dominant recent past.
That can be a perfectly reasonable signing. Good teams make calculated bets. The concern is whether Reinsdorf considers this the beginning of an offseason or the receipt he can wave whenever somebody asks about spending.
May should be a building block, not a conversation stopper.
Milwaukee’s example should push Chicago toward combining sharper baseball decisions with sufficient financial support. Instead, the danger is that ownership hears the Brewers won without a top payroll and remembers only the part about not spending at the top.
That misses the point. Efficiency is supposed to help build a winner. It should not become an excuse to keep asking the manager to manufacture one.
Venable deserves his moment. Taking this club from 102 losses to October baseball in one season is worthy of recognition. But an award for exceeding expectations should lead to higher expectations throughout the organization—especially in the owner’s office.
Celebrate the manager. Welcome May. Then keep building.
Here’s the thing, folks: The Brewers have shown what smart, adequately supported baseball can produce. Reinsdorf should take that as a challenge, not a coupon.
With that . . . White Sox fans finally have something worth believing in. The cheapest possible response would be to ask their manager to perform the same trick again without giving him enough help.
If you cannot play with them, then root for them.