The New York Yankees are setting up an offseason strategy that could shake up the New York baseball scene. The GM meetings started today and Yankees GM Brian Cashman wasted no time getting down to business. He called a meeting on Day 1 of the meetings with the Agent Scott Boras not only about retaining Juan Soto but also potentially prying Pete Alonso from their crosstown rivals, the Mets. While Soto’s future with the Yankees hinges on their ability to meet his high market value, Alonso adds another intriguing layer. With his immense power, consistent production, and strong presence at first base, Alonso is a prime candidate for the Yankees to target and potentially “steal” from the Mets—a move that would boost the Yankees’ lineup while sending a bold statement across the city.
Acquiring Soto from San Diego last December, the Yankees found themselves with a superstar whose blend of patience and power made an immediate impact. Soto’s stat line from this past season—.288 batting average, 41 home runs, 109 RBIs, and 129 walks—demonstrates why he’s one of the most highly regarded hitters in the league. Soto’s presence alongside Aaron Judge created a potent middle of the order, with the two forming one of the most formidable power duos in recent Yankees history. Not only did he deliver consistently in the regular season, but his clutch performances in the playoffs—including a game-changing three-run homer in the 10th inning of Game 5 in the ALCS—helped propel the Yankees to their first pennant since 2009. Now, as Soto hits free agency, he’s expected to command a landmark contract of $500 million or more.
Cashman has already been proactive in communicating with Soto and his agent, Scott Boras, to keep the star in New York. Following a conversation during the post-season with Soto where he made it clear that the Yankees want Soto long-term and are prepared to meet with him frequently to discuss terms. Soto’s career numbers—.282 average, 160 home runs, 499 RBIs, and nearly 700 walks—underscore his incredible plate discipline and offensive impact, traits that make him a cornerstone for any franchise. Locking him down would not only ensure the Yankees maintain one of the most productive hitters in the game but also prevent a rival team from scooping him up.
But the Yankees aren’t stopping there. As they look to construct a lineup built to contend for years, they’re eyeing Alonso, who’s also a free agent and looking to secure a big contract. Alonso’s five-year career with the Mets has been nothing short of remarkable: a .254 batting average, 192 home runs, and 498 RBIs, marking him as one of the league’s elite power hitters. He smashed 46 home runs with 118 RBIs last season alone, numbers that would give the Yankees’ lineup additional depth and power. The idea of Alonso in a Yankees uniform has the potential to not only transform the Yankees’ infield but also shift the power dynamic in New York baseball, as the Yankees aim to build a juggernaut lineup that could dominate the AL.
A move to sign Alonso from the Mets would undoubtedly ruffle feathers across the city, particularly given the Mets’ wealthy owner, Steve Cohen, who has made it clear that he’s committed to winning and has the resources to compete for top free agents. While Cohen would likely push to keep Alonso, Cashman and the Yankees are well aware that a high-stakes battle for his signature would be worth it. Bringing Alonso across town would strengthen the Yankees’ lineup while simultaneously weakening the Mets, making it a win-win for the Bronx Bombers.
Here’s the thing folks: For the Yankees, the offseason now centers around retaining Soto and potentially bringing in Alonso, both of whom could anchor the team’s offense for years to come. With Soto’s combination of discipline and power and Alonso’s ability to go deep at any moment, the Yankees could create one of the most intimidating lineups in baseball. Cashman has made it clear that the Yankees are prepared to invest in these stars to cement New York’s baseball dominance.
With that… The Yankees’ strategy reflects a commitment to aggressive roster building, aiming not only to retain their own stars but also to poach talent from rivals to assemble a powerhouse team. For fans, the prospect of Soto and Alonso staying in New York—and both potentially donning pinstripes—paints an exciting future. If Cashman succeeds, the Yankees could enter next season with a revamped lineup that boasts some of the league’s biggest bats, setting the stage for an explosive rivalry and a thrilling race for the top in the AL.
If you cannot play with them, then root for them.