Yet another Saturday where the unexpected became the norm in college football and those with the huevos to be daring enough to anticipate it are a bit more flush–just in time for Black Friday. THE ATHLETIC PULSE’ tag team of Alex Kirshner and Lauren Merola as usual summed up it with succintness and eloquence:
At the moment when we least expect it, college football reaches out and shakes us with a Saturday that stuns the season. On a day with just one ranked-versus-ranked matchup (No. 1 Georgia 34, No. 21 South Carolina 6), we got nine hours of national chaos.
The most shocking results occurred in the Big Ten…two different upsets, both in overtime:
- Michigan 18, No. 4 UCLA 16. This one took three overtimes, as the unbeaten Bruins lost both the game and their quarterback, Ty Dieffenbach (who himself was already a backup). That Michigan would win was far from a shock, given its elite defense. But the unit gave up a late tying drive before knocking Dieffenbach out of the game during the first play of OT. Third-stringer Madden Iamaleava (the sophomore brother of injured starter Nico) was way out of his depth as the game continued: UCLA did not get a first down after Dieffenbach’s injury.
- Washington 27, No. 8 Indiana 24. The Huskies blocked two Indiana field goals, including the tying attempt in overtime. The Hoosiers have been breaking down for weeks but kept winning close games … until now. Additional injuries on the offensive line, at linebacker and potentially at wideout will make everything even harder.
Entering the week, the Bruins and Hoosiers had clear paths to the Big Ten championship. That’s now a jumbled mess, though UCLA is still win-and-in against rival USC next week. (The No. 18 Trojans beat Maryland, 35-21, after trailing in the third quarter.) For different but overlapping reasons, neither UCLA nor Indiana is a sure thing for the Playoff.
And their college Stewart Mandel reminded in his FINAL THOUGHTS newsletter this morning:
UCLA may be in danger of getting the 2023 Florida State treatment…UCLA coach Bob Chesney has worked miracles just to get the Bruins this far, but he now has to face No. 18 USC (8-3, 5-3 Big Ten) next week with his third-string quarterback. The committee dropped an undefeated Florida State team from the four-team CFP because its third-string QB looked bad in an ACC Championship Game win. I don’t think UCLA wants to find out how it would treat a team that loses its last two games.
Mandel also chimed in with some other stellar examples of Big Madness:
After suffering through a decade of futility marked by excruciating big-game collapses, Nebraska fans finally got to be happy Saturday. Who cares if it took facing the worst Ohio State team in 15 years?
The Huskers (7-4, 4-4 Big Ten) ended a 31-game losing streak to ranked opponents with a 31-28 upset of the No. 14 Buckeyes (7-4, 5-3). Quarterback Anthony Colandrea, who’d struggled during his team’s recent four-game losing streak, gashed Ohio State in arguably his best performance to date. Nebraska had already re-signed Colandrea for next year with a lucrative deal that seemed premature at the time, but he and his team delivered some much-needed hope Saturday. Not much new to say about Ryan Day’s team, which suffered its third loss in four games.
After a 0-4 Big Ten start, Matt Campbell’s first Penn State team seemed to be righting itself in getting to 6-4. So much for that. In one of the most embarrassing losses in recent program history, Rutgers walked off the Nittany Lions 25-24 at Beaver Stadium thanks to an impromptu lateral by running back Antwan Raymond for a touchdown, followed by a successful 2-point conversion. Greg Schiano’s Scarlet Knights snapped an 18-game losing streak to the Nittany Lions, whom Rutgers had last defeated in 1988.
No. 15 Iowa (9-2, 6-2 Big Ten) is trying to make an 11th-hour CFP case. It won its fourth straight game Saturday, 34-17 at Illinois (6-5, 4-4), and will at least move up one spot given No. 14 Ohio State’s loss. The Hawkeyes don’t have much of a resume, though at this point it’s not so much different than Indiana’s. Arguably their best win was a 41-24 rout at 7-4 Washington, the team that just beat the Hoosiers. The problem for Kirk Ferentz’s team is that Oregon jumped the Hawkeyes last week and now may be heading to Indianapolis.
But perhaps they’ll get to settle it on the field. Among other scenarios, If USC (against UCLA), Oregon (against Washington), Indiana (against Purdue) and Iowa (against Nebraska) all win next week and Wisconsin beats Minnesota to solve a complicated tiebreaker, it will be Oregon vs. Iowa on Dec. 5.
And wouldn’t that be a fitting final championship game for the conference with the biggest lie of a name of all out there. For as ridiculous as it is to have two teams minutes for the Pacific Ocean representing the Atlantic Coast Conference or Texas State in the Pac-12 the very idea of a coast-to-coast melange now encompassing 18 teams being decided by two schools otherwise not qualifying at the moment for any post-season tournament berth is both poignant and alarming, especially in light of the prediction the PULSE pair offered up:
Playoff doomsday is now on the table. At the moment, my best guess is the Big Ten, the richest league in college athletics, will put two teams in the 12-team field. But it’s also possible the Big Ten only gets one bid. This would be a grave embarrassment in the last year before the CFP expands to 24 teams, championed by (guess whom) the Big Ten.
You do mean the Big Chai, don’t’cha?
Courage…